Polyphia – Be Not Afraid | Album Review

Despite being Gen Z, Polyphia fail to get down with the kids

The phrase “how do you do, fellow kids?” is usually tied with a photo of Steve Buscemi on 30 Rock, wearing a backwards cap and holding a skateboard. The joke is that he’s middle aged and out of touch, yet somehow Gen Z guitar icons Polyphia feel like they’re getting to that point well before they should be. Be Not Afraid feels like an attempt to grapple with modern popular genres, mainly TikTok phonk/modern digicore, but with virtuosic guitar lines over the top. There are flashes of obvious influence from other electronic artists, but never genres. There seems to be a contentedness to not be curious and to not understand what makes the genres they are pulling from work.

The production is the most interesting part, and even then it’s burdened by the need for guitars to be there. None of the guitar parts are even that interesting; there aren’t going to be a host of covers of songs like ‘The Goat’ and ‘Playing God’ from previous albums. An exception to this is ‘They Know Not What They Want’. The guitars do something interesting, and even then any semblance of artistic merit outside of flexing is missing.

There’s no real care for where they’re taking influence from, minus aesthetic appeal. Everything exists without reference, without influence, and without understanding why things work. Polyphia are taking influence from genres and scenes that thrive on singles, and stretching it to an album with no particular thought to why that might provide different challenges. The first single ‘Can You Feel It’ is still the stand out from the album, but it’s a single. It’s the bare minimum you would want to debut a new sound for a new era. The ravey chords alongside the heavy bass make it almost feel like something you might hear someone play in a DJ set, which is the original function of all the music they’re trying to rip. Unlike the rest of the album, it has replay value. ‘Deny the Flesh’ and ‘Devil Get Behind Me’ hav scant moments that were danceable, but there seems to be a fear of leaning into that. They still had to be Polyphia, they still had to have guitars there, even if they were unnecessary.

Be Not Afraid is a product of SoundCloud induced loudness wars arm races, where each song competes to be the loudest coming out of a phone speaker – which the album fails at as well – and it is an exhausting listen. It is an album where you can hear each request from the band for it to be louder. Even worse, the moments where the distortion is stripped back a bit are the moments that have some level of interest & ear candy, that draw you in. There are about 2 of these across the whole runtime.

Guitar virtuosos of days gone by always had their fixations; even Spinal Tap parodied this with the Indonesian folk music section of the film. The general western rock fixation of Fela Kuti and Afrobeat at least could be pointed back to, well, Fela Kuti. Many of those influences also came with things like different forms of harmony and interesting syncopation, rather than boring crushing 4×4 kicks that would get you very firmly thrown off the decks at your local squat/freeparty. ‘Deny the Flesh’ seems to be begging to go have some danceable drums, but then cowards out for more overly processed yet uninteresting guitar.

The vaguely biblical themes that appear throughout do not help. They seem to be there to give a sense of gravitas to music that does not justify it. It is purely aesthetic Christianity, and – like the rest of the album – does not seem to care to engage with the source material from which it came. Early in the album (the songs blend together), there is a sample from shock jock Alex Jones, where he proclaims that they are “turning the freaking frogs gay”. Why is this here? What does this contribute to the song? The relentless sampling of preachers alongside the purely aesthetic engagement with genres outside of shred guitar feels like artistic cowardice, but does just fall short of causing offence, or trying to inspire ridicule.. The other samples feel contrived as well. “Power In the Blood’ has the one vocal chop that is featured in ‘Dilemma’ by Nelly ft. Kelly Rowland, and ‘Fear God’ has one very popular riser that is in many different hip hop productions.All aesthetic signifiers, with no real love.

Be Not Afraid feels desperate to be cool, or even edgy. It fails at every attempt. Who is this for? Guitar nerds will bemoan the lack of guitar, and the electronic music fans will listen to the better music that it is cribbing from. Where else is there to go for this band? Will they fully lean into Tim Henson’s levels of androgynous attractiveness? What else is there to do especially if there’s no willingness to engage with music outside of the self-aggrandising bubble of guitar virtuosos, or whatever the TikTok algorithm decides to push next.

The closest parallel to this is likely Post Human: Nex Gen by Bring Me the Horizon, but that had ideas, even if not well executed. However, the influence could be traced, and collaborators could be found. Despite it not being fantastic, there is a sense that someone could hear it, become inspired, and make something better. There is no way this album can do that. It feels like something from an anonymous SoundCloud account that someone who you wish you didn’t add on Discord sent you.

Score:2/10
Polyphia